Near-instant rejections may have changed job search behavior

Near-instant rejections may have changed job search behavior

Dive Brief:

  • Automated screening processes are changing how applicants approach their job searches, with 54% of job seekers saying they adjusted their resumes after they received “an unusually fast rejection,” according to new research from job search platform JobAssist.
  • Among people who applied for at least one job in the last year, 46% said they got at least one rejection within ten minutes of submitting their application. Within that group, 81% said they believed they had been rejected by an automated or artificial intelligence-assisted system, and 76% said they didn’t believe a person had “meaningfully reviewed their CV” before the system rejected them.
  • This lack of transparency has left many U.S. job seekers exasperated. A recent study found that 60% of candidates said the most frustrating part of their job search was not knowing if an actual person had seen their resume. Automation and repetition have also affected how long even a promising candidate will stay engaged with the application process.

Dive Insight:

JobAssist’s survey of nearly 7,000 adults across the U.S., the U.K., Canada and Australia found that widespread hiring opacity is impacting both an applicant’s first experience and their subsequent job searches.

“A job rejection arriving within minutes can leave applicants questioning whether their qualifications were ever reviewed,” the report said. “With little information about how employers assess applications, candidates may interpret the speed of a decision as evidence of automated screening. That perception is beginning to influence what they do after being rejected, including how they prepare applications for other employers.”

Some applicants reported adjusting keywords or reformatting their resumes to reframe their work experience in order to accommodate automated screening processes. Part of the challenge for job seekers is that they’re trying to modify their applications based on screening criteria they cannot verify, using “the outcome of an earlier rejection to guess what future employers might prioritize,” per the report.

This can also impact whether a candidate will consider applying to other open positions at a company where they’ve been rejected. The survey found that 47% of applicants said an extremely fast rejection “made them less likely to apply to the same company again.”

Job seekers said that quick rejections made them question a potential employer’s credibility, with 58% saying a too-fast rejection made them less likely to believe any communications regarding “careful consideration.”

Even so, many applicants said they valued a quick response, and 73% said they would rather receive a quick rejection than be forced to wait a week or longer and not get a response. However, 68% said “a rejection arriving within minutes” was simply too quick “to represent a full review.” When candidates had experienced both almost instant rejections and later rejections, 64% said the later responses were more believable “as evidence that their application had been considered,” even if those responses arrived several hours later or the following day.

The lack of feedback regarding the application process has led many applicants to apply a “spray and pray” approach, with nearly half of respondents to a separate, recent survey reporting that they often apply to many roles in rapid succession. Another 25% said that hiring opacity had led them to apply “to any job that seems even remotely possible.”

This behavior has created a volume of applications that recruiters are struggling to get through, various reports say.